“Why Am I So Oversensitive?”
Being oversensitive can feel a blessing and a curse.
Do you often feel like you were born with the capacity to feel things that others just can’t?
Or lack the self protective ‘skin’ others seem to naturally have?
Are you emotionally sensitive?
“Oversensitive” is perhaps not the best term because it is a judgement. It implies that your level of sensitivity is ‘too much’, or not acceptable.
Other terms are ’emotionally sensitive’ or the trendy ‘highly sensitive person’ tag.
Being emotionally sensitive can look like the following:
- if someone raises their voice you run off or cry
- sad or violent films make you cry or feel deeply upset
- you might avoid people or situations that upset you
- things like music, art, and nature move you more than others
- sensory output (noise, lights, smells) can be overwhelming
- timeouts in quiet, calm places are things you need
- You suffer intermittent depression.
Can I be diagnosed as an oversensitive person?
There has been quite the hype around being a ‘highly sensitive person’ in the last few years.
It’s a buzz created by an American psychologist Elaine Aron, who coined the phrase with her series of successful books.
Aron’s main research paper looks at animal studies. It then connects this to research done on human personality traits to suggest that ‘sensitivity’ might be a trait we can be born with. I
It’s an interesting hypothesis. But it’s actually only that, and based on other people’s research at that. There are far too many other factors to yet claim we are just ‘born sensitive’.
Aron admits this herself in her main research paper. Its says, “personality differences can be related to many factors, including of course the physical and social environment, development of specialised skills through experience using them, and as a side effect of other inherited traits such as growth rate in nonhuman animals and body size and strength in human extraverts.”
And the hypothesis of ‘I am just born highly sensitive’ has a dangerous side. It can mean someone does not take the time to look at other contributing factors that can actually be effectively treated.
What Can Cause Emotional Oversensitivity?
Before writing off your oversensitivity as just something you were born with and can’t change, consider other possible contributing factors.
Childhood trauma is the leading contributor to emotional oversensitivity.
This can be physical, emotional, or sexual abuse. Childhood trauma throws a child into a sort of long-term PTSD, where they are always on alert. This can include emotionally.
Flawed parenting can also causes emotional oversensitivity.
Attachment theory suggests that you need at least one caregiver as a child who offers you unconditional love and is trustworthy. If your main caregiver was instead unreliable – if they only loved you when you were ‘good’, for example, of if they were mentally ill or emotionally unavailable – then you will grow up to have what is called ‘anxious attachment’. This leaves you overly attuned and responsive to other people’s actions.
The most important thing to note here is that both childhood trauma and unsuccessful parenting are issues that can be effectively treated with talk therapies.
Emotional sensitivity and psychological disorders
While being ‘highly sensitive’ is not a diagnosis, there are proper diagnosis that encompass some forms of emotional oversensitivity. These include:
Borderline personality disorder – often related to childhood sexual abuse, BPD sees you having strong, uncontrollable emotional responses in relationships.
ADHD – attention deficit hyperactivity disorder causes impulsivity, which can include emotional impulsivity (try our ADHD quiz to see if you might have it).
Major Depression – depression causes cycles of negative thinking so that we interpret everything as against us, then have bigger emotional responses than those around us understand.
Social anxiety – anxiety causes overthinking, which means we can be oversensitive.
Conclusion
If considering yourself as a ‘highly sensitive person’ (HSP) helps you understand yourself, and works to make your life easier and more fulfilled, wonderful. And if it means you focus your sensitivity in useful ways like being creative and empathetic, even better.
But if you find you are using being oversensitive as an excuse, then not so great. If you are opting out of relationships, for example, or not going after the career you want, because you are ‘too sensitive’, then that is not helpful.
And if you suspect you had childhood trauma or did not receive the love and care you needed when young, then it’s a very wise idea to reach out for support.
Difficult childhoods do not have to be life sentences. There are many types of therapy geared to help you. You can new ways of thinking and being that mean you are no longer controlled by your sensitivities, but can use them in ways that benefit you.
Want help with managing your oversensitivity? Harley Therapy connects you with highly experienced therapists in several London locations. Not in London? For affordable counselling worldwide, please visit our sister site harleytherapy.com .
Still have a question about being oversensitive? Post in the public comment box below.
Physical neurological illness can case High Sensitivity. Yes you have mentioned ADHD it there is also Autism and Chronic Pain. Chronic pain is caused by a hypersensitive CNS which can become so triggered into hypersensitivity by surgery, accident, Ehlers Danlos Syndrome, Ankleosing Spondilitis, overtraining, nothing at all or psychological trauma among other things. The body – mind wrongly believes it needs to send out pain warnings when there is no reason for any. Google “Central Sensitisation’ for more info ME, Fibromyalgia amd other conditions are also ones of Central Sensitisation. Childhood trauma or any trauma may contribute but doesn’t have to. Of course in reality the CNS cannot distinguish between the physical and the emotional and that is how we should be acknowledging this new medical paradigm. What are called psychological but are actually neurological behavioural manifestations of chronic pain are rarely discussed in the literature but Chronic Pain is in fact an ABI (Acquired Brain Injury) or TBI (Traumatic Brain Injury). I have not seen Elaine Aaron look at this as yet.
Really useful information for readers, thanks Rachel!
A lot of your article made sense except for “While being ‘highly sensitive’ is not a diagnosis, there are proper diagnosis for some forms of emotional oversensitivity. These include:”
There are umbrella terms for completely different conditions that, whilst it might be easier for a psychologist to included sensitivty under them, would actually complete misdiagnosis and likely leave the person untreated, or even worse on medication that in no way adressed their issues
Also, there is a massive difference between someone who say “sensitive to loud noises” and someone to whom the slightest negative comment might devastate them for days (due to aforementioned bad parenting etc) bot these people can be described as “highly sensitive” but they are two entirely different conditions. For example I get easily damage dby other people remarks even when they dont mean anything by them – but I love loud psychedelci rock concerts. It seems to me these umbrella terms used by psychologists are for convenience and in many cases “Pidgeon holing” people, whilst easier can lead to more trouble than good – people are complex beings and the nuances and differences between people are subtle.
Hi there. We take the stance that each person is an individual, not a diagnosis. Diagnoses change across cultures and history. We don’t, however, have any power over the diagnostic codes and current terminology for psychiatry, such as the DSM and the World Health Organisation’s ICD-10. These are not ‘umbrella terms’ in the article, they are the acceptable diagnoses at this time in history, decided by boards of experts who spend years finalising each version of these manuals. Sensitivity is not a clinical diagnosis, despite the popular book about HSPs. It remains recognised as either a personality trait (with a lot of positives) that doesn’t need diagnosing or medication, or a trait that can cause issues that mean talk therapy can help but a clinical diagnosis is not required. Or it is part of other diagnosable conditions that might but don’t always need meds, including those listed (the article suggests they are possible diagnoses for some forms of sensitivity, not that all sensitivity falls under one of them). Any psychiatrist or psychologist worth their salt would have no problems with recognising how a person’s sensitivity does or doesn’t fit into a diagnosis. There are of course bad psychiatrists, just like there are bad lawyers, doctors, writers…. And if you are in America, there is a high chance you will have drugs thrown at you as an answer regardless your symptoms. Drugs can manage symptoms, but a treatment plan including therapy can change some symptoms and at the very least give you life long tools to cope. If you aren’t satisfied with a diagnosis, we recommend you seek another opinion from another mental health expert, and do your research to find someone who deals with your issues. Best of luck, HT.
Hi there. Most if not all mental health issues and conditions are seen as existing on a spectrum, not as being set in stone or having only one meaning. For example, to qualify for a diagnosis of a personality disorder or something like schizophrenia, you have to meet a number of criteria from the list put forth by one of the diagnostic manuals, but not the entire list. There is a lot of room for differences. We are people, not mathematical equations, after all. The point of mental health diagnoses was originally just to help mental health professionals more easily and quickly help people, particularly those who were seeing several doctors at once. A sort of ‘medical short hand’. Unfortunately with the rise of the internet and all its misinformation these terms have become labels. Some people feel better and less alone with a label, others feel understandably trapped. As stated, we take the stance that each person is an individual, not a diagnosis, and it’s a stance many, many mental health professionals take. So you are making a lot of assumptions here, which is understandable, getting help can be scary. We think you’ll enjoy our article about diagnosis here https://www.harleytherapy.co.uk/counselling/a-personality-disorder-diagnosis-helpful-or-a-trap.htm. Don’t let your fear of being labelled stop you from finding a good therapist who can understand and help. Best, HT.
Hi there! What if an individual is highly sensitive but not sensitive to lights, is extraordinarily social, and maintains long healthy relationships? For example, let’s say this is someone who cries when seeing someone else cry or someone who gets easily triggered by certain things where they will end up feeling extremely emotional—or losing a family pet where he/she undergo depression because of it. What explains a highly emotional person? A highly emotional person to the point where their emotions take over and cant reason or function? Would this be something neurological? Or purely physiological?
Hi Sue, the list of symptoms would not imply that someone would have all of them at once. The different reasons for sensitivity listed in the article might shed some light on what is behind this, did none of them resonate? Although also to be considered that normal levels of empathy can make us cry when others do, and being depressed after the loss of a pet we love is not strange but actually normal. So might also be interesting to consider who you are comparing yourself to here and if they are really the best barometer to base a comparison on. And as the article also discusses personality traits can be a part of it. Best, HT.